The primary goal of Professional Insurance Enrollers is to be the difference maker for our clients and their employees.

PIE meets this goal by providing total access for wellness and benefits, reducing actual cost to employers, and making great service, education, and dependability a priority.  We consider it our responsibility to consistently investigate all concepts and products in the market, creating a workplace where everyone benefits!

Company History

Established in 2004 under the name First Secured Benefits, John and Chris Glaub created a brokerage with the primary goal of being the difference-maker for clients. A team of knowledgeable, hard-working agents willing to address the ever-changing health care and wellness market was assembled, and in 2010 the name Professional Insurance Enrollers (PIE) was officially adopted. A growing organization, PIE now works with local representatives in Fort Wayne, Indianapolis, Chicago, Louisville, Grand Rapids, and Cincinnati and is honored to have the privilege of servicing over 350 group clients in some capacity whether it be group health, supplemental, or ancillary benefits. The main headquarters in in South Bend, Indiana moments from the campus of Notre Dame.

Ready to get started?

Contact Us Today!
We made the switch to Professional Insurance Enrollers during a time when we were struggling with drastically increasing medical claims. We were struggling to get the help we felt as though we needed to improve upon our situation. Our Broker at the time was unable to offer any suggestions that we thought would help our situation. PIE came to us with new ideas and the readiness and willingness to help us navigate our way to a point that allowed us to put those changes in place. Since making the change to PIE, we have experienced marked improvements in our medical claims expense. They continue to help and guide us on a consistent basis.
Leigh Elliott | Operations Manager at Flexaust | Warsaw, Indiana
PIE has represented my company's group health insurance for over 10 years. They have supported us in a very professional manner during these uncertain market conditions. Their advice and willingness to understand our needs and aligning them with the dynamic health insurance marketplace that we face today have been very helpful to my company.
David Ziker | Owner of Ziker Cleaners Inc. | Mishawaka, IN
For 15 years we have trusted Professional Insurance Enrollers to handle our employee benefits…health, dental, vision, life, and supplemental insurance plans. We are extremely pleased with the outstanding service provided by PIE. They are very responsive and knowledgeable, offering a wide variety of products and services. I highly recommend Professional Insurance Enrollers!
Nikki Poertner | Assistant Controller at Ramco Engineering, Inc. | Elkhart, IN
PIE is great! Very supportive and they pay attention to detail. I couldn’t do my job in HR without them!
Lorie Harrison | Owner of Container Service Corporation | South Bend, IN
We have been with PIE for numerous years and have been very satisfied. They have used innovative ways to keep our health insurance premiums down without sacrificing our health insurance coverages. Would recommend PIE to anyone looking for a fresh approach to their health insurance coverage.
David Stopczynski | Controller at Knox Fertilizer | Knox, IN